Hi all,I am planning to deploy a small metro site-to-site VPN between two sites using the following equipment and requirements. I'd appreciate a nudge on the architecture and what would work best from your perspective.
Network equipment
-
2 × Flint 2 (v4.9)
-
1 × Brume 2 (v4.7; willing to use beta firmware if required)
-
1 × XVR with HTTPS/RTSP capabilities
-
2 × Zyxel GS1900-8HP
-
1 × Zyxel GS1200
-
2 × surge protectors
-
UPS
-
HE.net DDNS
Requirements
-
Site-to-site VPN primarily for managing the XVR and viewing/streaming video. Separate management and video access per user.
-
1–5 external/roaming users should have separate VPN tunnels/credentials and access the XVR remotely.
-
External users should ideally be restricted to the XVR rather than having access to the rest of either site's LAN.
-
If I make a mistake with the VPN/firewall configuration, I would strongly prefer not to have to travel to the remote site to recover it.
-
I will normally be physically present at Site 1, while Site 2 is the less convenient site to visit.
Site 1
-
Flint 2
-
GS1900-8HP
-
PON: 600 Mbps down / 400 Mbps up
-
Currently behind CGNAT, but I can request a public IPv4 address
Site 2
-
Flint 2
-
GS1200 or GS1900-8HP
-
DOCSIS: 200 Mbps down / 40 Mbps up
-
Public IPv4 address
-
XVR with approximately 5 analogue cameras connected to it
The cameras themselves terminate at the XVR over coax; the network connection is only to the XVR.
What I would particularly appreciate advice on
-
Where would you put the Brume 2 — Site 1 or Site 2 — and what overall topology would you use?
-
Would you put the Brume 2 in front of a Flint 2, or behind it? Should the switch sit before or after the Flint?
-
Is the classic arrangement of putting the Brume 2 at Site 2 in front of the XVR worth the additional travel/maintenance burden?
-
Would you use the Brume 2 as the WireGuard server and one of the Flint 2s as the site-to-site client?
-
Would you recommend separate WireGuard peers/tunnels for each user, with firewall rules allowing different users access to XVR management (HTTPS), video streaming (RTSP), or both?
-
Is Tailscale a viable alternative here? If so, how would you arrange the transit/subnet routers and exit nodes, particularly for the XVR?
-
Given the 40 Mbps upload at Site 2, are there any particular considerations for multiple simultaneous RTSP/sub-stream viewers?
My current priority is to get the XVR working reliably first, then finalize the physical/rack layout and implement the networking.
Thanks in advance for any suggestions or experience with a similar setup.
